Scholars Mind

Art of the Waiting World

We also pass through shared liminal spaces in the real world: train stations (and trains!), airports, elevators. Consider the following works, then discuss with your team: in what sense does each of them depict a liminal setting?

Seven artists on three continents, across two centuries, all stopped at the same kind of place: the room you are only in because you are going somewhere else.

Every work — at a glance

  • Rain, Steam, and Speed — J.M.W. Turner (painting)

    Turner's 1844 canvas of a Great Western Railway train crossing a bridge through a storm, everything solid dissolving into gold and grey except the black nose of the engine. A hare runs ahead on the track, easily missed. Liminal as pure motion: nobody in it has arrived or departed, they are simply mid-passage.

+ 15 more works explained inside

What to know

  1. 01
    In what sense is each of these a liminal setting? Set side by side they split two ways. Rain, Steam, and Speed and Gare Saint-Lazare give liminality as motion — Turner dissolves a train into weather, Monet paints the steam instead of the station — while Frith's platform and McCurry's Agra give it as suspension, a crowd held still between trains. The Yilan song and the Whitney elevators do both at once: you are moving, and you cannot see out.

+ 1 more insight inside

Across subjects

Before the railway, every English town kept its own noon by the sun, and Bristol ran about ten minutes behind London. A timetable cannot survive that, so in

Theme connection

"Are We There Yet?"

These artists found beauty in the places we hurry through, across two centuries and three continents. Are they celebrating the in-between or mourning it? Turner's train is thrilling and frightening in the same brushstroke, and Monet's steam is beautiful because it is busy erasing the station behind it.

Practice — a sample

ARTMonet wintered in London in 1870, where Turner's railway canvas hung. He was MOST likely to have —

  • A Bought a print
  • B Owned it briefly
  • C Praised it publicly
  • D Seen it there
  • E Copied it once

Sign in to answer and see why each option is right or wrong.

Keep reading the full lesson

The remaining insights, works, and practice come with full access — $29 solo or $59 for your 3-person team.

Unlock full access →

New here? Create a free account to read the free section.