Scholars Mind

Shortcuts and the Best Route

Urban designers know the frustration of watching unofficial trails sprout on perfectly manicured lawns. These are desire paths: the physical evidence of the shortest distance between two points. But, while a straight line is efficient, it isn’t always optimal. The “best” route is a shifting balance of speed, energy, and the unknown. With your team, consider the logic of the shortcut and the science of the scenic route. How do humans, animals, and even slime molds decide what way to go? Should we always follow the path of least resistance?

  • Traveling salesman problem | vector-based navigation | explore-exploit problem
  • Route elasticity | Braess’s Paradox | dead reckoning | the Steiner Tree Problem

Key concepts

User Equilibrium
The state a network settles into when every traveller picks their own fastest route. It is stable, and it is usually not the arrangement that would be quickest for everyone together — which is the gap a new road can fall straight into.

+ 1 more concept inside

Every work — at a glance

  • Desire Paths

    The worn trails that appear across grass wherever the official route takes too long — unfaked, continuous, free data on where people actually want to walk.

+ 8 more works explained inside

What to know

  1. 01
    Efficient and optimal are not the same word. The shortest line ignores energy, safety and everything you would have passed, so a desire path can be the fastest way across a lawn and still be the wrong route to pave — and a Steiner network gets shorter by adding junctions nobody asked for.

+ 1 more insight inside

Across subjects

London burned in 1666, and Christopher Wren offered the city a rational grid of straight avenues to replace the medieval tangle. It was rejected; owners rebuilt

Theme connection

"Are We There Yet?"

The question assumes one 'there' and one best way to reach it. Should planners fight the shortcut or pave it? A lawn is not a road — against the case that a desire path is the most honest user research ever conducted, free, continuous, and produced by the actual users.

Practice — a sample

SCIEach idea below helps plan efficient routes EXCEPT —

  • A Braess's Paradox
  • B The Salesman Problem
  • C The desire path
  • D Explore-exploit
  • E The arrival fallacy

Sign in to answer and see why each option is right or wrong.

Keep reading the full lesson

The remaining insights, works, and practice come with full access — $9.99/month or $29.99/season.

Unlock full access →

New here? Create a free account to read the free section.