Songs That Got Cut
In musical theatre, not all demos end up in the final product—but the Internet has allowed these unproduced numbers to find an audience. Consider the following demos that never quite got there. For each, discuss with your team: why do you think it was left out of the finished product?
- Aladdin | “Count on Me” (1994)
- Pocahontas | “First to Dance” (1995)
- Book of Mormon | “Family Home Evening” (2009)
- Dear Evan Hansen | “In the Bedroom Down the Hall” (2017)
Alan Menken wrote 'Count on Me' for Aladdin; it never made the film. Trey Parker recorded a sweet, funny number called 'Family Home Evening' for The Book of Mormon; cut. The internet now gives these orphaned songs an audience they never got in theaters — along with a puzzle: why were they left out?
Key concepts
- The Cut Song
- A completed, often excellent number removed from the final show or film — proof that 'finished' is defined as much by what's taken out as by what's kept.
- Killing Your Darlings
- The editing principle of cutting material you love when it doesn't serve the whole — a song can be genuinely good and still be the right thing to cut.
- Pacing And Cohesion
- A number can be brilliant alone yet slow the story, repeat another song's job, or break the tone — so it's removed to keep the whole moving and unified.
- The Internet Afterlife
- Cut content now lives forever online, finding fans it never reached in the theater — nothing is truly deleted, which changes what 'left out' even means.
What to know
-
01
A song's quality isn't enough to keep it — these cut numbers are often genuinely good, so removing them is about fit, not merit, the hard heart of editing: serving the whole over the part.
Keep reading the full lesson
The rest of this lesson — every key insight, the cross-subject connection, the Are We There Yet? theme tie-in, and practice questions — comes with full access.
Unlock full access →$9.99/month, or $29.99 for the whole season — see plans.
New here? Create a free account to read the free section first.